The Shift in Regulatory Strategy
The original proposal led by former Vice Chair Michael Barr suggested a 16% increase in capital requirements, which Wall Street banks argued could reach 20%. In response, the industry launched an extensive lobbying effort, suggesting the rules would impede lending and damage the broader economy. Under the current Trump administration, regulators have moved toward a draft that Federal Reserve Vice Chair for Supervision Michelle Bowman described as more balanced.
The new draft, combined with changes to other capital rules, will modestly reduce capital requirements for many lenders.
Impact on Large and Small Institutions
The revised proposal focuses on credit, market, and operational risks. It aims to right-size requirements to better capture risk while minimizing regulatory overlap. For instance, the changes would provide relief for mortgage lending and create a standardized risk measurement for smaller banks to encourage lending activities. While the largest and riskiest banks may still see slight capital increases under Basel, adjustments to the GSIB surcharge—a buffer for globally systemic banks—could result in a small net decrease in capital requirements for the biggest firms.
Perspectives and Future Steps
Critics of the new draft warn that reducing capital buffers could weaken the financial system, especially as markets face volatility from private credit conditions and geopolitical tensions involving Iran. Senator Elizabeth Warren has been vocal about the risks associated with these changes.
The changes put the economy at risk.
Conversely, research by Stephen Cecchetti of the Brandeis International Business School has indicated that higher capital requirements do not necessarily lead to reduced lending. The Federal Reserve is expected to vote on the new proposals shortly, followed by a public comment period. While regulators intend to move swiftly, the complexity of the rules suggests that finalizing the draft will be a multi-month process.